Best Afternoon Tea in Mystic, CT: Top 3!

Welcome to the quaint and charming town of Mystic, Connecticut, nestled along the picturesque coastline of the United States. As the sun begins its gentle descent, an enchanting tradition awaits you in this historical haven – Afternoon Tea in Mystic. Steeped in a rich maritime heritage and brimming with character, this coastal gem offers a delightful escape into a world of elegance and refinement. Join us on a journey where time seems to slow down, and the art of conversation flourishes over delicate tea sets and delectable treats. Immerse yourself in the warm ambiance of this coastal town and savor the time-honored ritual of Afternoon Tea, where every sip and every bite brings a touch of sophistication and a taste of Mystic’s distinctive charm. Whether you’re seeking a moment of tranquility or an opportunity to create cherished memories with loved ones, the tradition of Afternoon Tea in Mystic promises an experience that will linger in your heart long after the tea has been poured. Indulge in this timeless custom and discover the true essence of Mystic’s allure – a blend of maritime history, coastal beauty, and the simple pleasure of sharing tea in the company of kindred spirits.

1. Alice in the Village

Alice in the Village
27 Coogan Blvd # 26A, Mystic, CT 06355, USA
(860) 415-9625
View Menu
Open in Google Maps

Nestled in the heart of Mystic, Connecticut, Alice in the Village is a delightful Alice in Wonderland-themed Tea Room and Gift Shop that promises a whimsical experience like no other. As I stepped inside the cozy establishment, I was immediately captivated by the charming decor that transported me into the enchanting world of Lewis Carroll’s classic tale.

The ambiance was truly a feast for the senses, with whimsical paintings adorning the walls, teacups suspended from the ceiling, and playful details reminiscent of the Mad Hatter’s tea party. It felt like stepping into Wonderland itself, and the attention to detail was truly commendable.

The Afternoon Tea menu was a delightful selection of both sweet and savory treats, presented beautifully on a three-tiered stand. From delectable finger sandwiches filled with cucumber, smoked salmon, and cream cheese to freshly baked scones served with clotted cream and preserves, each bite was a delightful explosion of flavors. The pastries were equally divine, with an assortment of macarons, tarts, and cakes that catered to every taste preference.

What truly made the experience extraordinary was the impeccable service. The staff donned costumes inspired by the beloved characters from Alice in Wonderland, adding an extra layer of magic to the proceedings. They were attentive and knowledgeable, guiding us through the tea selection and making sure our cups were never empty.

The tea itself was a splendid selection of aromatic blends, ranging from classic Earl Grey to exotic fruit infusions. Sipping tea from dainty cups amidst the whimsical decor felt like a truly indulgent escape from reality.

The Gift Shop, adjacent to the Tea Room, offered an array of Wonderland-inspired souvenirs and gifts. It was a treasure trove for Alice in Wonderland fans, and I couldn’t resist taking home a memento of this enchanting experience.

Overall, Alice in the Village was an absolute delight. The attention to detail in the decor, the delectable treats, and the impeccable service made it an afternoon tea experience like no other. Whether you’re an Alice in Wonderland enthusiast or simply seeking a unique and magical tea experience, this place is a must-visit. It’s a little piece of Wonderland right in the heart of Mystic, Connecticut.

2. Tiger Lily Tea

Tiger Lily Tea
27 Coogan Blvd, Mystic, CT 06355, USA
(860) 415-9093
View Menu
Open in Google Maps

Tiger Lily Tea is an absolute gem nestled in the heart of Mystic, CT. From the moment I stepped inside, I was enveloped in a cozy and charming atmosphere that perfectly set the tone for a delightful afternoon tea experience.

Located on 27 Coogan Blvd, this little tea haven exudes warmth and tranquility, making it an ideal escape from the hustle and bustle of everyday life. The ambiance is beautifully decorated, with tasteful floral accents and soft lighting that creates an inviting and soothing space.

The afternoon tea itself was a delightful affair. The assortment of teas on offer was impressive, catering to both traditional and adventurous tea enthusiasts. From classic English Breakfast to exotic herbal blends, there was something for everyone. Each tea was steeped to perfection, boasting rich flavors that pleased the palate with every sip.

As for the delectable treats, Tiger Lily Tea did not disappoint. The tiered stand was adorned with a scrumptious array of freshly baked scones, adorned with clotted cream and homemade jam, alongside an assortment of dainty finger sandwiches that were bursting with flavorful fillings. And let’s not forget the mouthwatering selection of delicate pastries and cakes that added a sweet finishing touch to the experience.

The attentive and friendly staff at Tiger Lily Tea truly enhanced the overall experience. They were knowledgeable about the teas and dishes served, and their passion for providing exceptional service was evident in every interaction.

All in all, Tiger Lily Tea is a haven for tea enthusiasts and anyone looking to indulge in a quintessentially British afternoon tea experience. From the picturesque location to the exquisite teas and delectable treats, this charming tea house surpassed all expectations. I highly recommend Tiger Lily Tea to anyone seeking a serene and memorable afternoon tea experience in Mystic, CT.

3. Bleu Squid Breakfast and Bakery Cafe

Bleu Squid Breakfast and Bakery Cafe
27 Coogan Blvd Bldg 16, Mystic, CT 06355, USA
(860) 536-6343
View Menu
Open in Google Maps

Nestled in the charming town of Mystic, Connecticut, Bleu Squid Breakfast and Bakery Cafe is a delightful gem that has left a lasting impression on my taste buds. With its quirky name and unassuming facade, this little treasure trove of cupcakes and cheese exceeded my expectations.

The cafe’s location on Coogan Boulevard, housed in Building 16, provides a cozy and inviting atmosphere. As I entered, the aroma of freshly baked goods filled the air, instantly whetting my appetite. The interior was adorned with whimsical decor, creating a cheerful and welcoming ambience that invited patrons to linger and savor the moment.

The centerpiece of the cafe was undoubtedly their impressive array of cupcakes and cheese selections. The variety on offer was mind-boggling; from classic flavors to inventive concoctions, there was something to please every palate. Each cupcake was a work of art, with intricate frosting designs that almost seemed too pretty to eat. But, of course, I couldn’t resist diving in, and every bite was a burst of flavor and moist goodness.

Beyond their delightful cupcakes, Bleu Squid surprised me with their take-out grilled cheese sandwiches. As a fan of comfort food, I couldn’t resist giving them a try. The menu presented an array of options, ranging from traditional to gourmet, and I opted for a savory blend of gooey cheeses with a hint of caramelized onions. The sandwich was grilled to perfection, the bread golden and crispy, and the cheese oozing out invitingly. It was pure comfort in every mouthful.

The service at Bleu Squid was warm and friendly, with the staff going above and beyond to ensure a pleasant experience. They were knowledgeable about the menu and provided helpful recommendations, making the decision-making process a breeze.

Overall, my afternoon tea at Bleu Squid Breakfast and Bakery Cafe was a delightful experience. It’s a place where cupcakes and cheese come together in harmony, creating a haven for foodies and dessert enthusiasts alike. If you find yourself in Mystic, CT, do not miss the opportunity to indulge in the delectable treats and cozy atmosphere of this charming cafe.

Scroll to Top