Welcome to the charming seaside town of Cape May, nestled on the southern tip of New Jersey in the United States. Steeped in history and adorned with Victorian architecture, this picturesque destination offers much more than just sandy shores and ocean waves. One of its time-honored traditions, Afternoon Tea, invites you to indulge in an experience that exudes elegance and sophistication. As the sun begins its descent, visitors and locals alike gather in quaint tearooms and historic inns to savor delectable treats, aromatic teas, and the warm camaraderie of good company. Join us as we delve into the enchanting world of Afternoon Tea in Cape May, where tradition meets coastal charm and memorable moments await.
1. Tea By the Sea
Tea By the Sea, nestled at 405 W Perry St in the charming town of Cape May, NJ, is a delightful haven for tea enthusiasts and those seeking a wonderful afternoon tea experience. As soon as you step inside, you’re enveloped by the warm and inviting ambiance, making you feel right at home.
This quaint tea shop boasts an extensive selection of loose teas, catering to a variety of tastes and preferences. Whether you’re a seasoned tea connoisseur or a newcomer to the world of tea, their knowledgeable staff is more than happy to guide you through the choices, ensuring you find the perfect brew to suit your palate.
The highlight of Tea By the Sea is undoubtedly their impressive collection of fine china. Adorned with intricate designs and exquisite patterns, the tea sets evoke a sense of elegance and refinement. From delicate tea cups to ornate teapots, each piece exudes a sense of timeless charm, making the tea-drinking experience even more special.
Not just for adults, this delightful tea emporium also caters to the young ones with their charming children’s sets. It’s a wonderful way to introduce the little tea lovers to the art of afternoon tea, making it a memorable and enchanting experience for them too.
Tea By the Sea has also thoughtfully catered to collectors and enthusiasts with their miniatures collection. These tiny replicas of classic tea sets are a unique addition to the store, appealing to those who appreciate the intricate craftsmanship of miniaturized art.
As for the tea parties, the staff at Tea By the Sea go above and beyond to ensure every event is a resounding success. Whether you’re planning a cozy gathering with friends or a lavish celebration, their attention to detail and personal touch make each event truly special.
In conclusion, Tea By the Sea in Cape May, NJ, is a haven for tea lovers and a must-visit destination for anyone seeking an extraordinary afternoon tea experience. With its wide range of loose teas, stunning fine china, delightful children’s sets, and captivating miniatures, this tea shop is a testament to the timeless allure of tea-drinking traditions. It’s a place where the love for tea is celebrated, and every cup is a journey of taste and elegance.
2. Angel of the Sea
I had the pleasure of experiencing the delightful afternoon tea at Angel of the Sea in Cape May, New Jersey. This charming inn, nestled on 5 Trenton Ave, instantly transported me back in time with its 19th-century ambiance.
Upon arrival, I was warmly greeted by the friendly staff and guided to a cozy corner where the afternoon tea was set up. The atmosphere was inviting, and I couldn’t help but admire the quaint surroundings. It was like stepping into a bygone era, which added a touch of magic to the whole experience.
The afternoon tea spread was simply exquisite. A beautiful assortment of finger sandwiches, scones, and delectable pastries graced the table. The presentation was elegant, and it was evident that great care had been taken in preparing each delicacy.
The selection of teas was impressive, offering a range of flavors to suit every palate. From classic Earl Grey to refreshing fruit infusions, I found myself indulging in a delightful afternoon of tea-sipping bliss.
What made the experience even more special was the impeccable service provided by the staff. They were attentive, ensuring that my teapot was always full and that I had everything I needed to thoroughly enjoy my time.
In addition to the delightful afternoon tea, Angel of the Sea also offers charming accommodations, making it an ideal spot for a tranquil getaway. The idea of starting the day with a complimentary breakfast and ending it with a relaxing afternoon tea made my stay all the more memorable.
Overall, Angel of the Sea surpassed my expectations. If you find yourself in Cape May and seek a charming escape with a touch of history, I highly recommend indulging in their afternoon tea experience. It’s a truly delightful treat that will leave you with wonderful memories to cherish.
3. The Queen Victoria
Nestled in the heart of Cape May, New Jersey, The Queen Victoria exudes an old-world charm that transports you back in time. As I approached the quaint houses dating back to 1876, I couldn’t help but feel intrigued by the promise of an authentic afternoon tea experience.
Upon entering the establishment, I was immediately greeted by the warm and inviting ambiance. The decor exuded elegance and sophistication, mirroring the historic charm of the surrounding buildings. The soft aroma of freshly brewed tea and freshly baked scones filled the air, whetting my appetite for the delights to come.
The afternoon tea service took place on their beautifully furnished porches, adding an element of nostalgia and a serene view of Ocean St. The attentive and friendly staff made sure we were comfortable and well taken care of throughout the experience.
The tea selection was quite extensive, offering a variety of traditional and specialty blends. I opted for their house blend, and it did not disappoint. Served in dainty china cups, the tea had a rich and soothing flavor that perfectly complemented the assortment of treats before me.
Speaking of treats, the tiered trays presented an array of delightful finger sandwiches, freshly baked scones, and an assortment of delectable pastries. The sandwiches were light and flavorful, showcasing a variety of fillings, while the scones were perfectly crumbly and accompanied by clotted cream and jam. The pastries were a delightful finish to the spread, offering a mix of sweet and indulgent flavors.
The attention to detail in every aspect of the afternoon tea experience was commendable. From the beautiful presentation to the impeccable service, The Queen Victoria managed to capture the essence of a traditional English tea while infusing it with their own unique charm.
In conclusion, The Queen Victoria in Cape May, NJ, offers a delightful afternoon tea experience that is a treat for all the senses. Whether you’re a local looking for a relaxing afternoon escape or a visitor wanting to immerse yourself in the historical charm of the area, this old-world B&B will not disappoint. The combination of a picturesque setting, warm hospitality, and a delectable selection of teas and treats makes The Queen Victoria a must-visit destination for any afternoon tea enthusiast.
4. The Harrison
I recently had the pleasure of experiencing Afternoon Tea at The Harrison in Cape May, NJ. This elegant 1867 B&B, nestled at 613 Columbia Ave, exudes a classic charm that immediately transports you back in time.
Upon arriving at the picturesque location, I was captivated by the beautiful wraparound porch that adorned the building. The setting alone promised a delightful experience ahead. As I stepped inside, the ambiance was equally enchanting, with its period-inspired rooms tastefully decorated, perfectly complementing the historical charm of the place.
The Afternoon Tea service was a true delight. From the moment the server brought out the carefully arranged assortment of finger sandwiches, scones, and pastries, I knew I was in for a treat. Each bite was a wonderful fusion of flavors and textures, showcasing the culinary expertise of the tea room.
The highlight of the experience, undoubtedly, was the selection of teas offered. Their tea collection boasted a variety of blends, and I couldn’t resist trying a few. From the rich black teas to the fragrant herbal infusions, each cup was steeped to perfection, allowing me to savor every sip.
What truly sets The Harrison apart is its attention to detail and the seamless integration of its historical character into the experience. The period-inspired rooms and, in some cases, claw-foot tubs added an extra layer of authenticity that made the Afternoon Tea feel like a step back in time.
The service was impeccable throughout my visit, with the staff exuding warmth and knowledge about the teas and the history of the B&B. They created an atmosphere that made me feel both pampered and appreciated.
In conclusion, The Harrison in Cape May, NJ, is a hidden gem for anyone seeking an exquisite Afternoon Tea experience in a historic and elegant setting. Whether you’re a history enthusiast, a tea lover, or simply looking for a charming getaway, The Harrison is a must-visit destination that will leave you with cherished memories and a longing to return.
5. Coffee Tyme At The Beach
Nestled in the heart of Cape May, New Jersey, Coffee Tyme At The Beach is a delightful little haven that promises a memorable afternoon tea experience. Located at 315 Beach Ave, this charming counter-serve establishment exudes a welcoming vibe that draws both locals and tourists alike.
Upon stepping inside, I was immediately enchanted by the cozy atmosphere, with the aroma of freshly brewed coffee wafting through the air. The quaint and unpretentious interior instantly put me at ease, providing the perfect setting for a relaxing break from the bustling beachside.
As the name suggests, coffee is at the heart of this establishment, and their selection of hot and iced brews does not disappoint. The baristas are skilled in their craft, creating artful coffee creations that cater to a wide range of palates. Whether you prefer a rich and velvety latte or a refreshing iced Americano, Coffee Tyme has you covered.
Aside from their splendid coffee offerings, the array of baked goods displayed on the counter was hard to resist. From flaky croissants to mouthwatering muffins, each treat looked as inviting as the next. My sweet tooth led me to try their signature cinnamon roll, which turned out to be a delectable choice. Soft and buttery, with just the right amount of cinnamon goodness, it paired perfectly with my coffee.
For those seeking something more substantial, Coffee Tyme also serves breakfast sandwiches that are both hearty and satisfying. The combination of freshly baked bread, eggs, and savory toppings made for a delightful and energizing treat.
The staff at Coffee Tyme At The Beach were friendly and attentive, ensuring that every visitor felt welcomed and well taken care of. Their genuine smiles and helpful recommendations added to the overall warmth of the place.
In conclusion, my visit to Coffee Tyme At The Beach was a wonderful experience. From the inviting ambiance to the delightful coffee and treats, it’s an ideal spot to unwind and indulge in a bit of afternoon tea. So, if you find yourself strolling along Beach Ave in Cape May, don’t miss the chance to savor a little piece of coffee paradise at Coffee Tyme At The Beach.
6. Avalon Coffee of Cape May
Nestled on Gurney Street in the charming town of Cape May, New Jersey, Avalon Coffee is a delightful haven for tea enthusiasts and coffee aficionados alike. This snug and inviting café, with its warm and welcoming atmosphere, offers a delightful retreat for those seeking a respite from the bustling streets outside.
As you step inside, the comforting aroma of freshly brewed java greets you, instantly lifting your spirits. The interior exudes coziness, with its soft lighting and comfortable seating options, creating an ideal spot to unwind and enjoy a leisurely afternoon tea.
Avalon Coffee proudly boasts an impressive selection of java drinks, crafted with care and precision, catering to even the most discerning taste buds. Whether you prefer a classic cappuccino, a velvety latte, or a simple yet satisfying cup of black coffee, their skilled baristas have you covered.
Pairing perfectly with their beverage offerings are an array of delicious bagels and breakfast sandwiches, prepared to perfection. The mouthwatering scent of freshly baked bagels will leave you eager to savor every bite, while the breakfast sandwiches provide a hearty and scrumptious option to fuel your day.
One of the café’s standout features is its covered patio, a delightful spot to bask in the beautiful weather while sipping your tea or coffee. This quaint outdoor space enhances the overall experience, allowing guests to enjoy the fresh air and soak in the pleasant surroundings of Cape May.
The friendly and attentive staff at Avalon Coffee add a genuine touch to the overall ambiance. Their warm smiles and prompt service contribute to a relaxed and enjoyable visit, making you feel right at home.
Overall, Avalon Coffee of Cape May leaves a lasting impression with its cozy ambiance, delightful array of java drinks, and delectable food offerings. Whether you’re seeking a peaceful morning coffee or a delightful afternoon tea, this charming café is well worth a visit for anyone in Cape May, USA.
7. Elaine’s Cape May
I recently had the pleasure of experiencing Afternoon Tea at Elaine’s Cape May, a delightful venue located at 513 Lafayette St, Cape May, NJ. From the moment I stepped inside, I was captivated by the elegant ambiance that the place exuded.
Elaine’s Cape May is a hidden gem, offering not only a restaurant but also a charming pub and a relaxing outdoor bar. The afternoon tea was served in a beautifully decorated space, creating the perfect setting for a leisurely and refined experience.
The tea selection was impressive, featuring an array of aromatic blends that catered to various tastes. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, helping me navigate through the options and recommending the perfect tea to complement my palate.
As for the food, the assortment of finger sandwiches, scones, and pastries was exquisite. Each bite was a delightful journey of flavors and textures, showcasing the chef’s expertise in creating delectable treats. The presentation was as appealing as the taste, adding to the overall charm of the experience.
Elaine’s Cape May truly understands the essence of Afternoon Tea, making it a memorable affair that goes beyond just good food and drinks. It’s an opportunity to indulge in the finer things in life, and I thoroughly enjoyed every moment of it.
The combination of elegant decor, impeccable service, and delectable treats made my Afternoon Tea at Elaine’s Cape May a truly unforgettable experience. Whether you’re a local or a visitor to Cape May, this charming venue is a must-visit for anyone seeking a refined and delightful afternoon tea experience.
8. Magic Brain Cafe
I recently had the pleasure of visiting Magic Brain Cafe located at 31 Perry St in the charming town of Cape May, NJ. As I stepped inside, I was immediately greeted by the cozy and inviting ambiance of this wood-clad coffee shop.
The cafe’s atmosphere was relaxed and laid-back, making it a perfect spot for an afternoon tea break. The aroma of freshly brewed coffee and tea filled the air, tempting me to indulge in their delightful offerings.
As a tea enthusiast, I was pleased to find an excellent selection of teas available, catering to both traditional and adventurous tastes. From classic black teas to soothing herbal blends, Magic Brain Cafe had something to satisfy every tea lover’s palate.
The afternoon tea experience was complemented by a delectable array of sweets and baked goods on display. The sight of beautifully crafted pastries and cakes made it hard to resist trying them all. The scrumptious treats perfectly complemented the tea, creating a delightful combination of flavors.
The service was warm and friendly, adding to the overall positive experience. The staff was knowledgeable about the various teas and sweets on offer, making helpful recommendations and ensuring that every guest felt welcomed.
What stood out to me most was the cafe’s dedication to creating a memorable and enjoyable afternoon tea experience. The attention to detail in the presentation of the tea and treats demonstrated a genuine passion for their craft.
If you find yourself in Cape May, I highly recommend visiting Magic Brain Cafe for a delightful afternoon tea. Whether you’re a coffee lover or a tea enthusiast, this charming coffee shop offers a wonderful selection of beverages and treats in a relaxed and inviting setting. It’s the perfect spot to unwind and savor the simple pleasures of life.
9. Crepe May
Open in Google Maps
Nestled along the charming streets of Cape May, New Jersey, Crepe May is a delightful little gem that exudes a cozy and inviting ambiance. Located at 306 Washington St, it is conveniently situated for those exploring the town’s historical attractions or simply seeking a relaxing spot to unwind.
Stepping inside, the warm and welcoming atmosphere immediately captures your senses. The soft chatter of fellow patrons and the aroma of freshly brewed tea fill the air, creating a comforting and intimate setting for afternoon tea.
As I settled into my seat, I couldn’t help but admire the quaint decor that added to the overall charm of the place. The attention to detail was evident in every corner, from the floral accents to the tasteful vintage-inspired furnishings.
The tea selection at Crepe May was impressive, offering a diverse range of flavors to satisfy all palates. From traditional black teas to herbal infusions, each blend was thoughtfully curated to complement the delectable crepes on offer.
Speaking of crepes, they were undoubtedly the highlight of the experience. The menu presented an array of sweet and savory options, and I couldn’t resist trying a couple of each. The crepes were beautifully thin, with just the right amount of filling, making for a delightful treat that left me craving for more.
What truly stood out during my visit was the impeccable service provided by the staff. They were friendly, attentive, and knowledgeable about the teas and crepes on the menu, making recommendations that perfectly matched my preferences.
Crepe May is undoubtedly a hidden gem in Cape May, offering a wonderful afternoon tea experience that perfectly blends delectable treats, an inviting ambiance, and outstanding service. Whether you’re a local or a visitor passing through, I highly recommend making a stop here to savor this charming tea spot.
10. Bella Vida Garden Cafe
Nestled along the charming streets of West Cape May, Bella Vida Garden Cafe offers a delightful afternoon tea experience that leaves a lasting impression. As I stepped into the quaint locale, I couldn’t help but admire the serene ambiance and the allure of its garden patio. The setting was simply enchanting, perfect for a leisurely afternoon indulgence.
The cafe’s menu boasts a fusion of New American dishes, all-day breakfast options, and a delightful selection of vegan fare, catering to a diverse range of palates. The variety was impressive, ensuring that there was something for everyone.
Upon being served the afternoon tea, I was met with an assortment of scrumptious finger sandwiches, freshly baked scones, and an array of delectable pastries. Each bite was a burst of flavors, carefully crafted to perfection. The presentation added a touch of elegance to the whole experience, making it feel special and refined.
Accompanying the delightful treats was a selection of aromatic teas, providing the perfect complement to the savory and sweet components of the meal. The staff was attentive and knowledgeable, readily assisting in choosing the right tea to suit individual preferences.
What sets Bella Vida Garden Cafe apart is not just the mouthwatering cuisine but also the warm and inviting atmosphere. The garden patio, adorned with blooming flowers and greenery, added a sense of tranquility, making it an ideal spot to unwind and savor the moment.
Overall, my afternoon tea experience at Bella Vida Garden Cafe was nothing short of delightful. Whether you’re a tea connoisseur or someone simply looking for a charming escape, this cafe is a hidden gem in West Cape May that will surely leave you with a smile.
11. Hotel Alcott
I recently had the pleasure of experiencing Afternoon Tea at the charming Hotel Alcott in Cape May, New Jersey. This historic gem, built in 1878, exudes elegance with its Italianate architecture. Situated at 107-113 Grant St, the location is perfect for those seeking a relaxing retreat by the sea.
As I entered the hotel, I was immediately captivated by its polished and sophisticated ambiance. The interior oozes old-world charm, and I could sense the rich history that the walls hold. The high-end rooms are a testament to the hotel’s commitment to providing a luxurious experience to its guests.
The Afternoon Tea itself was a delightful affair. Served on a picturesque veranda, the setting added a touch of romance to the experience. The selection of teas was impressive, catering to various preferences and palates. I opted for a classic Earl Grey, and it was brewed to perfection.
Accompanying the tea were a delectable assortment of finger sandwiches, scones, and pastries. The sandwiches were elegantly presented and filled with a delightful blend of flavors. The scones were freshly baked and served with clotted cream and preserves, a true highlight of the tea service. The pastries, too, were indulgent and beautifully crafted.
The staff at Hotel Alcott were attentive and courteous, making sure that every detail was taken care of. Their passion for providing exceptional service was evident throughout the entire experience.
While Afternoon Tea at Hotel Alcott does not come with an elaborate assortment of treats like some other venues, it’s the refined ambiance and the historical charm that set it apart. The combination of a 19th-century Italianate setting and the delightful tea service created an unforgettable afternoon. If you’re looking for a taste of elegance and a step back in time, Hotel Alcott is the perfect destination for Afternoon Tea in Cape May.
12. Jardin At The Hugh
I had the pleasure of experiencing a delightful afternoon tea at Jardin At The Hugh in Cape May, NJ. Tucked away on 653 Washington St, this beautiful restaurant is a haven for those seeking eco-friendly, plant-forward, and French-inspired cuisine.
The moment I stepped in, I was captivated by the ambiance – a perfect blend of elegance and coziness. The restaurant’s commitment to sustainability was evident, with its focus on using local, organic, and seasonal produce. It’s no surprise they were recognized as the best dining spot at the Shore by Craig Laban.
As I settled in for my afternoon tea, I couldn’t help but admire the thoughtfully curated prix-fixe menu. Each item was a work of art, showcasing the natural flavors of the fresh ingredients. From delectable finger sandwiches to delicate pastries, every bite was a revelation.
What impressed me the most was the restaurant’s dedication to catering to various dietary preferences. As a vegetarian, I’m always on the lookout for places that offer more than just a token dish, and Jardin At The Hugh exceeded my expectations. With an array of vegetarian and vegan-friendly options, I felt valued as a guest.
The attentive staff added to the overall experience, ensuring that my tea was always warm and my cup never empty. Their knowledge of the menu and willingness to accommodate special requests was commendable.
Overall, my visit to Jardin At The Hugh for afternoon tea was a memorable one. From the outstanding cuisine to the eco-conscious approach, the restaurant left a lasting impression on me. If you find yourself in Cape May and looking for a culinary journey that celebrates nature’s bounty, this is the place to be.
13. Beach Plum Bakery & Cafe
The Beach Plum Bakery & Cafe, nestled at 484 W Perry St in Cape May, NJ, proved to be a delightful surprise during my afternoon tea experience. Tucked within the charming West End Garage, a building with an interesting history that started as a garage and gas station, this cafe has transformed into a year-round haven for shoppers since its launch by Cape Resorts in 2009.
The atmosphere was warm and inviting, with a perfect blend of vintage aesthetics and modern touches. As I stepped inside, the aroma of freshly baked goods and aromatic teas greeted me, setting the tone for a cozy tea session.
The selection of teas was impressive, offering a variety of traditional and unique blends to cater to all tastes. I opted for their signature house blend, and it did not disappoint. Served in elegant teapots with quaint teacups, the presentation added an extra touch of sophistication to the experience.
Now, let’s talk about the treats! The bakery lived up to its reputation, boasting an array of delectable pastries and cakes beautifully displayed on the counter. Each item was a work of art, and I couldn’t resist trying a few. From flaky scones to rich chocolate cakes, the quality of ingredients and skillful craftsmanship were evident in every bite.
What truly stood out during my visit was the impeccable service. The staff was friendly, knowledgeable, and attentive without being intrusive, creating a comfortable and relaxed ambiance. They were more than happy to offer recommendations based on personal preferences, making the whole experience even more enjoyable.
While sipping on my tea and savoring the delightful treats, I couldn’t help but admire the unique setting of the West End Garage. The blend of history and contemporary charm provided a perfect backdrop for an afternoon tea rendezvous.
In conclusion, my visit to Beach Plum Bakery & Cafe was a memorable and delightful experience. With its cozy ambiance, exquisite pastries, and impeccable service, this hidden gem in Cape May is a must-visit for anyone looking to indulge in a soothing afternoon tea session. Whether you’re a local or a visitor to this beautiful town, the Beach Plum Bakery & Cafe should definitely be on your list of places to explore.
14. Coffee Tyme At The Mall
Located at 414 Washington St in Cape May, NJ, Coffee Tyme At The Mall is a charming coffee shop that lives up to its reputation as the number one coffee spot in Cape May, as per TripAdvisor. As soon as I stepped inside, I was greeted with the delightful aroma of freshly brewed coffee, setting the perfect ambiance for a cozy afternoon tea experience.
The place boasts an impressive track record, having been awarded the Best Coffee in Cape May for four consecutive years (2015, 2016, 2017, and 2018). This alone piqued my curiosity and elevated my expectations.
The afternoon tea selection did not disappoint. The tea offerings were diverse, catering to both traditional and adventurous palates. From classic black teas to soothing herbal blends and delightful fruit infusions, there was something for everyone. I particularly enjoyed their house blend, which had a robust yet smooth flavor, just the way I like it.
Accompanying the tea were their freshly made baked goods, which were undoubtedly a highlight. The scones were warm, crumbly, and paired exceptionally well with clotted cream and jam. The assortment of pastries and cookies added a delightful touch to the entire tea experience.
Apart from the tea and baked goods, the menu also offered a variety of breakfast sandwiches, which I couldn’t resist trying. They were freshly prepared and provided a satisfying savory option to complement the sweet treats.
The staff was friendly and attentive, adding to the overall pleasant atmosphere of the place. They were knowledgeable about their offerings and helped me choose the perfect tea to suit my taste preferences.
The cozy interior with comfortable seating made it a perfect spot to relax and enjoy some quality time with friends or even on my own with a good book.
In conclusion, my visit to Coffee Tyme At The Mall was a delightful experience. The accolades and positive reviews are well-deserved, as their commitment to providing excellent coffee, delicious baked goods, and warm hospitality truly shines through. If you find yourself in Cape May and are in need of a coffee fix or a relaxing afternoon tea, I highly recommend stopping by this gem of a coffee shop.
15. Magnolia Room
I recently had the pleasure of experiencing Afternoon Tea at the charming Magnolia Room in Cape May, NJ. Situated at 301 Howard St, this historic venue exudes elegance and charm, creating the perfect ambiance for a delightful afternoon treat.
The highlight of the experience was the seasonal selection of Southern classics, featuring mouthwatering fried chicken and delectable crab cakes. Each bite was a perfect blend of flavors, reminiscent of traditional Southern cuisine.
The historic setting added a touch of nostalgia to the afternoon, making it feel like stepping back in time to a more refined era. The attention to detail in the decor and the attentive service provided by the staff elevated the entire experience.
The Afternoon Tea at Magnolia Room was a delightful journey through scrumptious delicacies served in a picturesque setting. If you find yourself in Cape May and yearning for a taste of Southern charm, this is the place to be.
16. The Southern Mansion
Afternoon Tea at The Southern Mansion in Cape May, NJ was an enchanting experience steeped in history and elegance. The grand 1860s mansion, adorned with antique furnishings and period features, provided the perfect backdrop for a delightful tea time.
Nestled on 720 Washington St, the location exuded charm and sophistication, inviting guests to step back in time and relish in the refined atmosphere. The sprawling gardens surrounding the mansion added a touch of tranquility, setting the stage for a relaxing afternoon.
Upon entering the mansion, the warm welcome from the staff immediately made us feel at home. The attention to detail in the decor transported us to a bygone era, and the captivating stories shared about the mansion’s history only added to the overall experience.
The Afternoon Tea selection itself was a delightful treat. A wonderful assortment of finger sandwiches, scones, and delectable pastries adorned the table. Each item was skillfully prepared, showcasing the chef’s expertise and a dedication to quality.
The tea menu was impressive, offering a diverse range of flavors to suit every palate. From classic black teas to refreshing herbal infusions, every sip was a moment of pure bliss. The staff was knowledgeable about the teas and readily provided recommendations based on our preferences.
As we savored the scrumptious bites and sipped on our teas, time seemed to slow down. It was evident that The Southern Mansion put careful thought into curating an afternoon tea experience that honored tradition while embracing modern comforts.
Overall, our Afternoon Tea experience at The Southern Mansion was nothing short of exceptional. The combination of the historic setting, charming ambiance, delectable treats, and attentive service made it a truly memorable occasion. Whether you’re a history enthusiast, a tea lover, or simply seeking a moment of elegance and indulgence, this gem in Cape May is an absolute must-visit.
17. Tommy’s Folly
Nestled in the heart of Cape May, New Jersey, just off the lobby of the historic Congress Hall, lies the charming Tommy’s Folly. This delightful gem beckons with its inviting blend of a General Store, Boutique, and Coffeeshop, offering a unique experience for locals and visitors alike.
Upon stepping inside Tommy’s Folly, I was immediately drawn to the beautifully displayed Cape Resorts merchandise. The store exudes a sense of nostalgia, transporting you to a bygone era while showcasing an array of tasteful and captivating items. From locally crafted trinkets to souvenirs that capture the essence of Cape May, there was no shortage of treasures to peruse.
But it wasn’t just the shopping that drew me in; it was the promise of a relaxing afternoon tea that had piqued my interest. I settled into a cozy corner of the Coffeeshop area, where the ambiance was warm and welcoming, and the scent of freshly brewed tea filled the air.
The tea selection was diverse, with a range of classic and exotic blends to choose from. I opted for a soothing Earl Grey with a hint of lavender, and I must say, it did not disappoint. The tea was expertly brewed and served in elegant porcelain cups, elevating the experience to a true afternoon delight.
Complementing the tea were delectable pastries and treats, prepared with finesse. The scones were a highlight, served warm with a dollop of clotted cream and house-made berry preserves. Each bite was a delightful balance of crumbly texture and indulgent sweetness.
The staff at Tommy’s Folly were attentive and friendly, making me feel like a cherished guest throughout my visit. They exuded genuine passion for their craft and were more than happy to share insights about the history of Congress Hall and the local community.
In the end, my afternoon tea at Tommy’s Folly was a delightful experience, a perfect blend of history, elegance, and taste. Whether you’re a history buff, a tea enthusiast, or simply seeking a charming escape in Cape May, this hidden treasure is well worth a visit. Tommy’s Folly truly embodies the essence of Cape Resorts and leaves you with fond memories to cherish.
18. Out There Coffee
Located at 315 Ocean St, Washington St UNIT 22, Cape May, NJ, Out There Coffee is a hidden gem that has quickly become my favorite spot for a delightful afternoon tea experience. From the moment I stepped inside, I was drawn in by the cozy and inviting ambiance that made me feel right at home.
The highlight of this charming coffee shop is undoubtedly their locally roasted coffee and espresso. The baristas here are true artists, skillfully crafting each drink with precision and passion. My cup of cappuccino was rich, smooth, and had the perfect balance of coffee and velvety milk foam. It was evident that they take pride in their coffee-making process, and the result is a memorable and satisfying brew.
The afternoon tea spread at Out There Coffee is not only about beverages, but also includes an assortment of healthy snacks and delightful treats. I indulged in their freshly baked pastries, which were scrumptious and paired beautifully with my cappuccino. The attention to detail in both taste and presentation was impressive and added to the overall experience.
Beyond just providing excellent drinks and snacks, Out There Coffee exudes a welcoming and encouraging atmosphere. Their motto, “Inspiring others to get Out There and do what makes them happy!” is evident in the friendly service and the community vibes within the coffee shop. It’s a place that encourages you to take a moment to relax, enjoy your cup of tea or coffee, and simply be yourself.
Overall, Out There Coffee is a hidden oasis for tea enthusiasts and coffee lovers alike. With their locally roasted coffee, expertly crafted beverages, delectable treats, and inspiring ethos, this coffee shop has won my heart. If you find yourself in Cape May, NJ, I highly recommend paying a visit to Out There Coffee for a truly delightful afternoon tea experience.
19. Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant
I recently had the pleasure of experiencing afternoon tea at Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant, and I must say, it was a delightful and memorable experience. Located at 1301 Beach Ave in Cape May, NJ, this charming eatery is nestled in an elegant 1907 beachfront mansion, which adds an extra touch of romance and allure to the entire setting.
The moment I stepped into the restaurant, I was captivated by the breathtaking views that surrounded me. The location by the beachfront allowed for picturesque scenes, making the ambiance truly exceptional. The combination of the stunning ocean vistas and the vintage charm of the mansion created a perfect backdrop for a relaxing and enjoyable afternoon.
As for the afternoon tea itself, it exceeded all expectations. The spread featured a delectable selection of American fare, with an assortment of finger sandwiches, scones, pastries, and desserts that were both visually appealing and scrumptious. The flavors were well-balanced and showcased the expertise of the culinary team.
The service was attentive and friendly, adding to the overall pleasant experience. The staff’s knowledge of the menu and their willingness to accommodate individual preferences made the afternoon tea even more special.
In conclusion, the afternoon tea at Peter Shields Inn & Restaurant is a must-try for anyone looking to indulge in a delightful culinary experience amidst charming surroundings. Whether you’re a local or a visitor to Cape May, this place offers a unique and memorable treat that will surely leave you with fond memories of a wonderful time spent by the beachfront in a beautiful 1907 mansion.
20. Chill: Smoothies & Crepes, Cape May
If you find yourself strolling along the picturesque streets of Cape May, New Jersey, in search of a delightful afternoon treat, look no further than Chill: Smoothies & Crepes. Located at 301 Beach Ave, this charming spot offers a delightful blend of relaxation and indulgence.
As I stepped into Chill, I was greeted by a warm and inviting atmosphere. The interior had a lovely coastal vibe, reflecting the seaside charm of Cape May. The place exuded a sense of tranquility, making it an ideal spot to unwind and enjoy a peaceful afternoon.
The Afternoon Tea experience at Chill was truly a delightful affair. The menu boasted an array of enticing options, from delectable crepes with various fillings to refreshing smoothies bursting with fresh fruit flavors. It was evident that the ingredients used were of high quality, and each dish was skillfully prepared.
The highlight of the Afternoon Tea was undoubtedly the crepes. Served warm, they were thin, light, and exquisitely folded with an assortment of sweet and savory fillings. Whether you had a preference for fruit-filled delights or savory combinations, there was something to cater to every taste bud.
Accompanying the crepes were the smoothies, which were a refreshing complement to the meal. Bursting with natural goodness, these beverages provided a delightful mix of flavors, leaving a pleasant aftertaste that perfectly balanced the indulgent crepes.
The staff at Chill were friendly and attentive, ensuring that every aspect of the experience was enjoyable. The service was prompt, and the servers were more than happy to provide recommendations and cater to individual preferences.
In conclusion, Chill: Smoothies & Crepes in Cape May is a hidden gem for those seeking a relaxing Afternoon Tea experience. The combination of delectable crepes, refreshing smoothies, and the serene coastal ambiance made for a truly memorable visit. Whether you’re a local or a tourist, this charming establishment is well worth a visit to savor a delightful afternoon treat.
Hi there! I am Roy Davis, a passionate storyteller and traveler. I have always had a love for adventure and discovering new cultures, which led me to start AfternoonTeaing. Through my blog, I share my afternoon tea experiences and insights from my travels, along with helpful tips and recommendations to inspire others to see the world.
